www.ScrantonStation.com
Erie Lackawanna N-Scale ModelingAtlas 48052, Erie Lackawanna GP-7 Phase I #1213Atlas 48152, Erie Lackawanna GP-7 Phase II #1409Life-Like 7948, Erie Lackawanna EMD SW8 #362
 DC v DCC
 
Contents
Home
Up
Latest News
Our Story
Scranton in N Scale
Model Inventory
Modeling Topics
Trains We're Ridden
Acknowledgements
Links
Site Map

 
Inside This Section

The World According to DC

The Gulf Summit & Susquehanna Valley Railroad from the Nine N-Scale Layouts book is designed for DC operation with 4 throttles. Below is the block diagram schematic that I wired up. There are some extra blocks in it compared with the design in the book, but not too many and mainly on the lower level main.

Block wiring color guide
Lower level main Lower level yard Upper level main Upper level reversing track Interchange track

This is how I originally wired the layout. I had never heard of DCC and didn't know any different.

The wiring from the book allowed for 4 throttles as follows:

  • Throttle A & B - control by either throttle anywhere on the lower level main or lower level yard
  • Throttle C & D = control by either throttle anywhere on the upper level main or upper level reversing track
  • Any throttle to either interchange track

Well, this just did not make much sense to me with respect to how I wanted to run the layout. This required two changes of throttle to run a train out of the lower level yard, up the grade to the top, around the top and back down again. This was not how I wanted to operate.

I saw the lower level as the main part of the layout and so, I sacrificed one of the upper level throttles (D) and, instead, wired the output of throttle A or B to where the throttle D would be wired. This meant that throttle A or B could control anywhere that D had been planned to control, i.e. the top and the interchanges. Couple that with the fact that A or B could control a train on the lower level and the interchanges and you have the capability to control a train anywhere from either the A or B throttle.

I can now run a train not only on the lower level (standard capability of the original plan), but up the interchange tracks (original plan) and then anywhere around the top (the modified wiring plan). Thus the two changes of throttle became no change of throttle

But I still need to make sure that the block switches are set correctly. All 24 block switches plus the A/B selectors.

And I had an eight year old and, sometimes, his eight year old friends too. Try explaining this to them and see the enjoyment drain right out of their faces.

Then I heard of DCC

Reading up on it, that sounded like exactly what I wanted. But how easy would it be to convert to DCC?

Not hard as it turns out, given that I had already modified the layout so that you could control anywhere on the track with either of the throttle A or throttle B.

The steps:

  • Set every block so that it was controlled by the throttle A.
  • Disconnected all three of the throttle A, B & C.
  • Bought a Digitrax Zephyr system
  • Connected the Zephyr up to where the throttle A used to be connected.

Now, every block was receiving the DCC track voltage and signal. Presto, instant DCC in 5 minutes

Ok, the reversing look still required the manual switching of polarity, just as before. But, this sure was simple to switch. FWIW, I bought a Digitrax AR-1 to automate the reversing loop polarity switch.

Done. Finished. Simple as that!

If I'd wired it per the book, it would not have been much more complicated. Step #1 would have had me set all the upper blocks to throttle C and step #4 would have had me connect the Zephyr to the inputs for both throttle A and throttle C.

You can find out more about Digitrax products by searching the web, or by going to the company website here or the Yahoo discussion group here

And now it's simpler for my son and, especially, his friends!

 
 
Erie Lackawanna - N Scale Modeling
 
Last updated: 02/19/2009